Premiere Pro vs. Pinnacle Liquid Edition at DVinfo.net

Gino Terribilini · March 17th, 2004, 03:12 AM

First off, ROAR @ Pinnacle for having no plans to develop a compatability patch for using Pro-ONE system with Premiere Pro.

Now that that's out of my system, has anybody used Liquid Edition and Premiere Pro? Which is better? I have never used Liquid Ed. so i have no idea what its about. Any thoughts?

George Ellis · March 17th, 2004, 06:11 AM

I only tried the Premiere demo which was based on an earlier version. At the time, I was using either Studio 8 or Magix Deluxe 2. So, I just cannot really compare, but...

I did upgrade from S8 to Edition 4.5, LE 5.0, and now Liquid Edition 5.5. The only things that could improve are Audio editing and DVD mastering. The audio editor is basic and there are better tools. That may change as Studio now supports VSF and rumour is that they will be supported in LE eventually.

The DVD is basic, but does pretty good. For me, I would like multi-angle, better menu transitions, and AC3 support. I can use Impression for multi and DVD Lab for the rest if I need it. AC3 may be coming as S9 supports a very basic form of it.

I like it. I hear folks whine that "it has a steep learning curve." When you are using Pro tools, they all have steep learning curves. There are some good tutorials and you can buy training DVDs from 3 companies now.

David Stoneburner · March 17th, 2004, 09:17 AM

I switch over to Edtion 5 then to LE 5.5 and have been editing with it since August. I really like it now, a little bit of a learning curve, but going from Premiere 6.5 to Pro will be a bit of a learning curve as well, not as much though. It has a great color correction tool and is very stable. I mainly switch because my system didn't seem to have a enough power for Pro, I was using a 1900+ Athlon at the time. It seems that Pro needs a pretty powerful processor to work well, more than 6 or 6.5. The best thing to do is try the demo of Premiere and then goto an LE demo if there is one near you. That is what sold me and they are having traveling demos all over. It also depends on what you are doing. I keep 6 on my system to work with my DV500 card for certain projects, plus I can edit Quicktime files with Premiere if need be.

Paul Tauger · March 17th, 2004, 11:31 AM

For what it's worth, I gave up on Pinnacle when they stopped supporting the ProOne. I bought the upgrade to Edition 5.5, but was completely flummoxed by the user interface. Ultimately, the availability of 3rd-party products and plugins for Premiere drove my decision, and I got Premiere Pro. As soon as I can scrape together $700 or so, I'll do a competitive upgrade to a Matrox RT board.

March 17th, 2004, 03:12 AM	#1
Gino Terribilini Regular Crew Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Santa Rosa, CA Posts: 91	Premiere Pro vs. Pinnacle Liquid Edition First off, ROAR @ Pinnacle for having no plans to develop a compatability patch for using Pro-ONE system with Premiere Pro. Now that that's out of my system, has anybody used Liquid Edition and Premiere Pro? Which is better? I have never used Liquid Ed. so i have no idea what its about. Any thoughts?

March 17th, 2004, 06:11 AM	#2
George Ellis Trustee Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Suwanee, GA Posts: 1,241	I only tried the Premiere demo which was based on an earlier version. At the time, I was using either Studio 8 or Magix Deluxe 2. So, I just cannot really compare, but... I did upgrade from S8 to Edition 4.5, LE 5.0, and now Liquid Edition 5.5. The only things that could improve are Audio editing and DVD mastering. The audio editor is basic and there are better tools. That may change as Studio now supports VSF and rumour is that they will be supported in LE eventually. The DVD is basic, but does pretty good. For me, I would like multi-angle, better menu transitions, and AC3 support. I can use Impression for multi and DVD Lab for the rest if I need it. AC3 may be coming as S9 supports a very basic form of it. I like it. I hear folks whine that "it has a steep learning curve." When you are using Pro tools, they all have steep learning curves. There are some good tutorials and you can buy training DVDs from 3 companies now.

March 17th, 2004, 09:17 AM	#3
David Stoneburner Major Player Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: Orlando, FL Posts: 493	I switch over to Edtion 5 then to LE 5.5 and have been editing with it since August. I really like it now, a little bit of a learning curve, but going from Premiere 6.5 to Pro will be a bit of a learning curve as well, not as much though. It has a great color correction tool and is very stable. I mainly switch because my system didn't seem to have a enough power for Pro, I was using a 1900+ Athlon at the time. It seems that Pro needs a pretty powerful processor to work well, more than 6 or 6.5. The best thing to do is try the demo of Premiere and then goto an LE demo if there is one near you. That is what sold me and they are having traveling demos all over. It also depends on what you are doing. I keep 6 on my system to work with my DV500 card for certain projects, plus I can edit Quicktime files with Premiere if need be.

March 17th, 2004, 11:31 AM	#4
Paul Tauger Wrangler Join Date: Sep 2002 Location: Los Angeles (recently from San Francisco) Posts: 954	For what it's worth, I gave up on Pinnacle when they stopped supporting the ProOne. I bought the upgrade to Edition 5.5, but was completely flummoxed by the user interface. Ultimately, the availability of 3rd-party products and plugins for Premiere drove my decision, and I got Premiere Pro. As soon as I can scrape together $700 or so, I'll do a competitive upgrade to a Matrox RT board.