Camera Comparison/Workflow Options Flow Chart

[Jeff Cottrone]

I remember someone posing a similar question like this after NAB, but haven’t heard anything about it since. I would love to have some sort of huge camera comparison/workflow option flow chart. Something like this:

Let’s say the top level has camera choices: RED, Silicon SI-1920, Panasonic HVX200, Canon XL HI, JVC GY200…

The next level down has recording options: 4K 60p, 2K 120p, 1080 60p, 1080 60i, 1080 30p, 1080 24p, 720p…

The next level has codec options: REDCODE, Cineform, DVCPRO HD, MPEG2…

The next level has degree of compression: uncompressed, 5:1, 4:1, 2:1...

The next level has recording media options: REDCODE, Cineform RAW, HD-SDI, P2, HDV, DV….

The next level has NLE compatibility: FCP, Premiere, Avid…

You get the idea…

So it would work like this:

Whatever camera I select at the top level affects all the choices below it. If I choose the Panasonic HVX200, everything below that it doesn’t offer is grayed out (like REDCODE and Cineform RAW…). Then if I go to the next level down and choose 1080 30p, other options below would be grayed out (like HDV and DV). This way, not only can you see the options of each camera, but you can also see your workflow options.

So the chart would need to be organized with the widest options at the top. Maybe it could even be made with the ability for the user to drag and drop the order of the levels. I’m not at all programming savvy, so I don’t know the limitations, or even how long this would take to make. But I can’t imagine anyone (who doesn’t already know everything) who wouldn’t love the ease of such a chart.

Here’s a few more qualities that could be included on other levels. I’m sure there are many others.

CCD or CMOS…
CCD size (1/3”, 2/3”)
Lens options (Primes…)
Lens adapter compatibility (P&S, M2…)
Number of XLR inputs