SxS cards have less capactiy after each shoot

[Doug Jensen]

Originally Posted by Craig Seeman

What's not to like?

Does it allow you to create subclips?

Can I see thumbnails?

Can I playback clips?

Does is show all the same metadata as XDCAM Transfer?

Does it automatically gather all the clips from the various sub-folders within the BPAV folder on the card and put them all in one place (of my choosing) on the destination hard drive?

Does it allow re-naming of clips during the transfer?

Will the imported MP4 files show up and play within Adobe Bridge? Bridge compatibility is mandatory for my workflow.

Will the imported MP4 files run within QuickTime player?

I have to have two backups of everything I shoot, and it doesn't matter to me if one copy is an MP4 and one copy is an MOV. So, skipping XDCAM Transfer and having two MP4 backups would save me no space at all. Maybe a little importing time, but that doesn't matter to me.

[Mike Chandler]

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Will the imported MP4 files show up and play within Adobe Bridge? Bridge compatibility is mandatory for my workflow. .

How are you using Bridge, Doug? Is that for file organization?

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

I have to have two backups of everything I shoot, and it doesn't matter to me if one copy is an MP4 and one copy is an MOV. So, skipping XDCAM Transfer and having two MP4 backups would save me no space at all.

Can you assign the drive where the mov's are stored as they're created?

[Craig Seeman]

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Does it allow you to create subclips?

Yes in FCP. You use File Import. It's a plugin, not a program.

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Can I see thumbnails?

Yes

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Can I playback clips?

Yes

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Does is show all the same metadata as XDCAM Transfer?

Yes

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Does it automatically gather all the clips from the various sub-folders within the BPAV folder on the card and put them all in one place (of my choosing) on the destination hard drive?

No. It's a plugin. You use File Import. There's no program such as XDCAM Transfer. Import as a file as if it was any other MOV file ready to use.

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Does it allow re-naming of clips during the transfer?

It's a plugin. Files are simply imported as if they were already MOV.

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Will the imported MP4 files show up and play within Adobe Bridge? Bridge compatibility is mandatory for my workflow.

Good question but so far it works in every Quicktime based app I've tested with.

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

Will the imported MP4 files run within QuickTime player?

Yes. Plugin works in all Quicktime apps I've tested. I can import the MP4 in Compressor or Telestream Episode and use their TC Burn in feature to make Windows dubs of the clips without having to first wrap to MOV for example.

Originally Posted by Doug Jensen

I have to have two backups of everything I shoot, and it doesn't matter to me if one copy is an MP4 and one copy is an MOV. So, skipping XDCAM Transfer and having two MP4 backups would save me no space at all. Maybe a little importing time, but that doesn't matter to me.

I do a lot of short turnaround work. Imagine shooting 2 hour press conference and having to get it out that day. Not having to rewrap to MOV is a major time savings. I have two backups also. One to Optical Disk and another to Hard drive of the BPAV. No need to make a wrap to MOV which would be a third copy for me.

[Doug Jensen]

Craig,

Thanks for the info. It won't fit my workflow, but it looks like a good product for the right person.

[Doug Jensen]

Originally Posted by Mike Chandler

How are you using Bridge, Doug? Is that for file organization?
Can you assign the drive where the mov's are stored as they're created?

I use Adobe Bridge to organize all my stock footage, graphics, music clips, sfx clips, and other elements that I use on a regular basis while I'm editing. I have a dedicated 1TB drive on my system for those elements, plus other drives that are connected as needed.

Whenever I'm editing, Bridge is open and running. I can browse through the drives and preview clips, etc. from right inside Bridge (but it doesn't recognize MP4 files).

When I find something I want to use in my project, I can just drag and drop the file(s) straight from Bridge and onto my timeline or into a bin.

Without using Bridge, there is no good way to see what a file is before you import it into the FCP project.

To answer your other question, yes, you can control exactly where MOVs are stored when you import them with XDCAM Transfer.

[Sverker Hahn]

Originally Posted by Heath McKnight

I heard that you shouldn't delete clips from your computer.

Why not? I delete the BPAV folder all the time ...

[Craig Seeman]

Deleting Clips with ClipBrowser is fine.

The problem with deleting clips from the computer itself is that apparently computers may place invisible files on the card which may result in an error message when using the card in the camera.

[Heath McKnight]

Originally Posted by Sverker Hahn

Why not? I delete the BPAV folder all the time ...

See the conversation we've been holding here.

Heath

[Heath McKnight]

Originally Posted by Craig Seeman

Deleting Clips with ClipBrowser is fine.

The problem with deleting clips from the computer itself is that apparently computers may place invisible files on the card which may result in an error message when using the card in the camera.

This is what I was talking about earlier--erasing them manually from your Mac or PC vs. camera or Clip Browser.

heath