24p

[William LiPera]

This may have been discused already. Sorry if it has been. When a clip is used and it has 2.3.3.2 or 3.2 pulldown does vegas automatically remove the redundant frames if the the project is set to 24P. Do you need to set the frame rate of the time line to 24 as well. Thanks

[David Jimerson]

You should work in a 24p project (use one of the presets; no need to change anything). Otherwise, Vegas will leave the pulldown in.

Check out this:

http://www.david-jimerson.com/Vegas24pBasics.zip

[Chris Barcellos]

Hey David:

Any changes to your primer when doing 1080 24p HDV from the Canon HV20 ?

[David Jimerson]

Yeah. None of it applies. :)

Vegas can't remove the pulldown from the HV20 stream; no pulldown flags for it to work with.

[Steve Szudzik]

I found a 24p workflow that works fairly well for the HV20 at the below site: I haven't done too much with it myself, but I've run a few sample 24p clips through this workflow. Wonder whether there might be an easy way to script this up between Vegas and VirtualDub.

http://hv20.com/showthread.php?t=44

--Steve

[Peter J Alessandria]

Originally Posted by David Jimerson

Yeah. None of it applies. :)

Vegas can't remove the pulldown from the HV20 stream; no pulldown flags for it to work with.

David - do you know if this applies to the Sony V1U files as well? I've seen people having similar issues in Vegas at least with regard to pulldown removal on their V1U files. So perhaps the "no pulldown flags" applies to 24p HDV files in general and not HV20 specifically (meaning... hopefully Vegas or some other NLE will come up with a way to do automatic pulldown removal for 24p HDV files. Wishful thinking?)

[David Jimerson]

Originally Posted by Peter J Alessandria

David - do you know if this applies to the Sony V1U files as well? I've seen people having similar issues in Vegas at least with regard to pulldown removal on their V1U files. So perhaps the "no pulldown flags" applies to 24p HDV files in general and not HV20 specifically (meaning... hopefully Vegas or some other NLE will come up with a way to do automatic pulldown removal for 24p HDV files. Wishful thinking?)

To my knowledge, it also applies to the V1U. But I assume that will change in an update or in V 8.0. Just makes sense that it would.

[Douglas Spotted Eagle]

Vegas 7 correctly removes pulldown from V1U-acquired footage, whether it's shot in 24p or 24A modes, recorded to tape or acquired from the DR60 HDD recorder unit.

[David Jimerson]

Any word on whether the HV20 will be supported in an update -- at least as an option for manual removal?

[Chris Barcellos]

Okay. Review time for me. I shoot 24p on my HV20. It looks different and "filmic" when I look at it on my component feed to my LCD HD monitor.

I capature the same footage, and I think it looks the same when I play in on Window Media player.

So is the media player doing pull down removal ? Or am I imagining that I am seeing a filmic feel, and will it be different when I actually remove the pull down ?

I have posted some footage shot in 24p without doing any removal, and while it plays fine on my media player system, others complain that it does not come out well. I am assuming there system of video card is not handling it. Thoughts ?


Finally, if Vegas does V1U 24p, is it possible it does HV20 24p ? Are they the same file systems ?

[David Jimerson]

No, no pulldown removal.

For the same reasons that movies you watch on TV don't suddenly look like video, 24p retains its aesthetic even in a 60i stream. Remember, every Hollywood movie you've ever watched on a standard TV was shot at 24 fps and had pulldown inserted in order to be shown on a 60i TV -- yet it still looks like 24 fps film.