Michael Bodel
January 17th, 2010, 02:13 PM
This is sure to unleash a cacaphony of "this question has been answered" responses, but believe me I have been reading posts for 4 hour now, and as fascinating as all the 2:3 pulldown talk is, I still cannot figure what I am doing wrong. Most info is about HDV rather than SD (unless I am incredibly confused)
I own the GY-HD100. Thinking I would make my life simpler, I shot some dance footage in SD mode. I have captured it into FCP 5.1.4 with standard NTSC 29.97 settings. I also tried the DV-NTSC 24p (23.98) Easy Setup, as well as the "DV-NTSC 24p (23.98) Advanced Pulldown" Easy Setup, which I didn't expect to work because my footage was not shot 24Pa.
Being that this i dance there is lot's of movement, in all cases of capturing I see tons of interlacing. I believe this is normal because I have not done the Reverse TeleCine. Right?
Here is 10 sec. of that footage captured at 29.97fps:
http://www.mbodel.net/video/clip.29.97.mov
Now I opened that clip in Cinematools 2.0 and click "Rev Telecine", and select 23.98fps The result has removed the interlacing, but everything looks terrible. Like a pixely glow around the dancer on the left. Here's that footage:
http://www.mbodel.net/video/clip.revtelecine_23.9.rev
Please tell me what I am doing wrong. My ultimate goal is editable footage to make a work sample DVD and publish to the web. No need for true 24p'ness for film or anything.
thanks.
michael
I own the GY-HD100. Thinking I would make my life simpler, I shot some dance footage in SD mode. I have captured it into FCP 5.1.4 with standard NTSC 29.97 settings. I also tried the DV-NTSC 24p (23.98) Easy Setup, as well as the "DV-NTSC 24p (23.98) Advanced Pulldown" Easy Setup, which I didn't expect to work because my footage was not shot 24Pa.
Being that this i dance there is lot's of movement, in all cases of capturing I see tons of interlacing. I believe this is normal because I have not done the Reverse TeleCine. Right?
Here is 10 sec. of that footage captured at 29.97fps:
http://www.mbodel.net/video/clip.29.97.mov
Now I opened that clip in Cinematools 2.0 and click "Rev Telecine", and select 23.98fps The result has removed the interlacing, but everything looks terrible. Like a pixely glow around the dancer on the left. Here's that footage:
http://www.mbodel.net/video/clip.revtelecine_23.9.rev
Please tell me what I am doing wrong. My ultimate goal is editable footage to make a work sample DVD and publish to the web. No need for true 24p'ness for film or anything.
thanks.
michael