View Full Version : Need advice on NLE for PC


Randy Painter
June 10th, 2011, 09:34 PM
Leaving apple products. Mac pro's just to darn much. Edited it FCE and iMovie 6HD. Nothing professional but some home stuff and a few friends weddings. Looked at avid and premier. Seems both are still 32 bit. I built the following:
Dual quad core westmere E5640 2.66 Ghz
24GB ram
ATI 6950
Win7 pro 64

Been on Mac past 5 years. Windows the previous 15 yrs. Been reading the forums of both NLE's. Seems allot of complaints on both. I used to shoot with a panny hmc150. Sold it am currently researching for something else. Still using my Sony SR11 for now. What would work with the least headaches in windows? I hate getting half way through my work to get a lock up and lose everything. Still learning win7, which is a humongous change from XP, but seems good so far. Suggestions from folks currently using these would be appreciated.

Michael Wisniewski
June 10th, 2011, 10:16 PM
Most popular PC NLEs: Avid Media Composer, Adobe Premiere, Sony Vegas & Edius. They all have inexpensive "light" versions for around US$99. Choosing an NLE is a very personal thing. Best to download the demos and try them all yourself. On the PC I like Sony Vegas best, but YMMV.

Just to muddy the waters, FCP X is supposed to be released this month for US$299.00.

Good luck.

Randy Painter
June 11th, 2011, 07:37 AM
Been kind of holding off until fcx gets released but dont have a decent mac computer to run it. I bought a 2010 mini after selling my 2008 mac pro to get me by but editing AVCHD will probably still need a hefty machine. Apple went nuts with the prices on current mac pro's so built my own for half the price. Ill take your advice to give the trials a shot. Was hoping to find some insight on these programs before i find out the hard way.

Allen Vodi
June 19th, 2011, 07:44 PM
If you're looking for consumer (easy) editors check out PowerDirector from Cyberlink. It may fit your needs. Trial version available, runs in 64 bit mode, handles the popular HD formats.