Shaun Murphy
March 22nd, 2006, 11:02 PM
After many hours of reading, researching I have narrowed it down:
I am floating down the Colorado River through the Grand Canyon. I love taking pictures and really enjoy editing movies on my G5 Mac (single 1.6ghz wtih over 1 gig ram) I hope to document the trip, get some exciting footage and some great scenery shots to preserve the memory. I am having trouble choosing... Do I go 3CCD OR HD?
Color vs. Clearity.
Lets break it down:
PROS
3CCD - Better color, The colors in the canyon.. It would be a shame to lack color quality. Lower Cost... basically it is coming down to the PV-GS500 from Panasonic ~$700 --- (PVGS400 is hard to find and over $1100) & finally the computer can easily handle the standard DV editing and DVD burning.
HD - Better clearity, It would be great to re-live the experience on my 52" HD television is Crystal Clear "you can see every crack in the wall" Clearity. It is only a few hundred dollars more ($999)
CONS
3CCD - Well it isn't HD
HD - Can my CPU handle the HD load? No HD-DVD's so I can't even share the HD experience unless we play it on my Camcorder on my TV.. Will I regret not having an HD on a once in a lifetime trip .
So there you have it. I know I by looking back that the 3CCD might make more sense. But there are so many reviews about Eye Popping Details from the HC1!
It is too bad that there is no way to try these out, even for a day so i could experience the difference. Playing with one at the Dept. Store just doesn't cut it. I have toyed with the idea of buying both, just to be able to answer the question as to which one I like best. Sony's color is supposed to be better than the average 1CCD camera. In a year from now there will be HD-DVD's and I can easily upgrade to a computer that can handle the HD if needed.
I need somebody to tell me... "Shaun, it's too early to buy the HD, Go for the color" Or "Shaun, The Sony image is Killer, and my G5 can handle it", Maybe you have one and the color's great....
Please Help,, Thank You
I am floating down the Colorado River through the Grand Canyon. I love taking pictures and really enjoy editing movies on my G5 Mac (single 1.6ghz wtih over 1 gig ram) I hope to document the trip, get some exciting footage and some great scenery shots to preserve the memory. I am having trouble choosing... Do I go 3CCD OR HD?
Color vs. Clearity.
Lets break it down:
PROS
3CCD - Better color, The colors in the canyon.. It would be a shame to lack color quality. Lower Cost... basically it is coming down to the PV-GS500 from Panasonic ~$700 --- (PVGS400 is hard to find and over $1100) & finally the computer can easily handle the standard DV editing and DVD burning.
HD - Better clearity, It would be great to re-live the experience on my 52" HD television is Crystal Clear "you can see every crack in the wall" Clearity. It is only a few hundred dollars more ($999)
CONS
3CCD - Well it isn't HD
HD - Can my CPU handle the HD load? No HD-DVD's so I can't even share the HD experience unless we play it on my Camcorder on my TV.. Will I regret not having an HD on a once in a lifetime trip .
So there you have it. I know I by looking back that the 3CCD might make more sense. But there are so many reviews about Eye Popping Details from the HC1!
It is too bad that there is no way to try these out, even for a day so i could experience the difference. Playing with one at the Dept. Store just doesn't cut it. I have toyed with the idea of buying both, just to be able to answer the question as to which one I like best. Sony's color is supposed to be better than the average 1CCD camera. In a year from now there will be HD-DVD's and I can easily upgrade to a computer that can handle the HD if needed.
I need somebody to tell me... "Shaun, it's too early to buy the HD, Go for the color" Or "Shaun, The Sony image is Killer, and my G5 can handle it", Maybe you have one and the color's great....
Please Help,, Thank You