Hi,

I've been using an nvidia geforce 6600 LE with premiere pro 2.0 to edit HDV (form an FX1) and I'm not happy with it. When it optimizes the monitor and the TV performance everything looks WAY too dark. So, I'm thinking about selling this graphic card and buying a new one.

Any advices?

For accurate monitoring, you should use firewire out to a TV or (better yet) a broadcast monitor.

This will avoid issues with interlacing, field order, Premiere not showing things right, pixel aspect ratio / resizing, video card overlays or weird video card settings, etc.

Ok, is there anyone who can advise me on a GOOD and FAST graphic card to work with premiere pro 2.0. I know I'm asking for much here, but I don't want to have to sell an organ to be able to buy it.

may not be of immense help to you, but have you checked the Adobe website for approved video cards? I know AVID does. I guess you may want to look at things like H264 acceleration in hardware etc

MATROX PARHELIA APVe!

I usually don't capitalize with such fervor but I love this card with a passion. If your interest is editing, it's better to have a card that's designed for it in the first place. NVidia is for gaming. Recommended by Cineform, compatible with Adobe, displays three monitors (or two monitors and an SD/HDTV) at once, even suitable for the latest games! Killer. Just killer.

It's around $350 street.

Search ebay, you'll get some results as low as $320.

MATROX PARHELIA APVe!

I usually don't capitalize with such fervor but I love this card with a passion. If your interest is editing, it's better to have a card that's designed for it in the first place. NVidia is for gaming. Recommended by Cineform, compatible with Adobe, displays three monitors (or two monitors and an SD/HDTV) at once, even suitable for the latest games! Killer. Just killer.

It's around $350 street.

Search ebay, you'll get some results as low as $320.

THAT is what I wanted to hear! I've searched the web and askeed around but I never got the answer I wanted to hear "if you need a good graphic card for video editing which one is the one". Thanks, Ben!

I was checking on the MATROX PARHELIA APVe (289€) and it really sounds like a winner. I also checked the more expensive Parhelia PCI 256MB (509€). Do you think it's worth the extra $?

even suitable for the latest games! Killer. Just killer.


I agree with everything you say, except for that last quote. I don't know what you consider the "latest games" but this card is not in that league. It will play some older titles well, and can do some of the classics in surround (3 screen) but it no way is it currently competitive as far a 3d gaming. Not close.

Matrox cards do not have good OpenGL. This effects many video editing programs and most new games. We no longer recommned them to our customers.

I just posted a new article on our site that I think you will find helpful:
DIY–GPU: Picking the right graphics card for your NLE workstation
http://www.videoguys.com/DIY-GPU.html

Gary

I read your article, Garry, and it really helped me a lot. Not the problem is that you advise one graphic card to premiere and another one to magic bullet users...and I use both. Would magic bullet's perfomance increase a lot by using the FX1500 has over the FX560?

rafeal - good point about the article. I'm going to have to explain this better. How's this:

While the 560 will get the job done for P Pro, the FX1500 is the better card. It's just a bit of overkill for P Pro users. If you also use plug-ins that have Open GL support (Magic Bullet, Borix FX) or you're using After Effects, then you want to go for the FX1500 or higher. The added performance of these cards will make your use of these programs more productive.

FX560 = good for Premiere Pro
FX1500 = Good for Premeier Pro and better for AE/Boris/Magic Bullett
FX3450/3500 = worth the added investment for power After Effects users.

Gary

Thanks a bunch, Gary. I might be visiting you online store very soon ;-)

I just posted a new article on our site that I think you will find helpful:
DIY–GPU: Picking the right graphics card for your NLE workstation
http://www.videoguys.com/DIY-GPU.html

GaryMaybe I just missed it but there didn't seem to be any advice for FCP users. Do you guys deal with FCP at all?

we do a little FCP. We're not nearly as hardware savy w/ Mac as PCs. I will be adding a section on for FCP users down the road.

Gary

i do not really see the point to change a card just because the picture looks too dark.
Yes, nvidia has a problem with overlay that displays considerably different.
It is really annoying when you work into premiere with a still image with a particular contrast/luminosity on the monitor, and when you preview, it switches to another contrast/luminosity setting.
But a simple trip to the control panel of the nvidia card can fix this.
I see no reason to change a card for this reason only, especially if the new card could show the same problem.

I don't really think you get the problem. I thought I had it fixed by updating the graphic card control panel, but now the problem is different. I edit everything on premiere and on the timeline everything looks perfect (brightness/contrast/saturation/etc), but when I export it (with any codec/compressor at all) it looks WAY less dark than what I wanted it to look. I tried calibrating the monitor using the graphic cards' control panel, using the adobe gamma, using the monitor's own calibration controls, and I even bought one of those HUEY claibrators. The problem is always the same. Bottom line is: you can calibrate everything EXCEPT the image on premiere's timeline. Whenever I tried these calibration tools, the image on the timeline didn't change at all and everything else did. Before having this graphic card (it came with my new pc) I had a simple matrox gs400 and I never experienced this problem. I really don't know what else to do. My options simply ran out.

Here's some links that may be of help for deciding on a graphics card for your Adobe NLE system:

If you have AE:
http://www.adobe.com/products/aftereffects/opengl.html

For PP2.0:
http://www.adobe.com/products/premiere/search_result.html?manuSearchVar=1&modelSearchVar=0&supportSearchVar=0&brand=&dataFormat=&version=2.0&device=graphic&format=