Quote:
Originally Posted by Thomas Smet
Doesn't the XLH1 say HDV on the side?
|
Ah, but that's on the right side... everyone knows it's what's on the left side that *really* counts! Oh but wait, it's on the EVF as well.
Quote:
HDV is native to this camera. Just like DV and P2 recording are native to the HVX200 and DVCAM is native to the DSR570.
|
Once again it all boils down to what its buyers will primarily use it for. HDV on this camera is not as big of a selling point as its other features.
Quote:
I almost get the feeling that Canon thinks HDV sucks which is why they don't want people to feel as though this is a HDV camera.
|
No, not true, that's actually more of my doing than anything else.
Quote:
HDV is the native recording format of the H1 so it is HDV.
|
It certainly is HDV, but it's also more than that.
Quote:
If the deck could be removed you may have a case but since the deck is built in this is not a camera head but a camcorder.
|
Are dockable cams even being made anymore? It is a camcorder, but it'll most likely be used as a camera head.
Quote:
While some users may use it strictly for studio work with SDI great super but it is still a HDV camera that is being used as a camera head.
|
True, but 1.485Gbps is not "HDV."
Quote:
So are us users that would use it as a HDV camera stupid for using it that way? Should we not use it to record HDV because it isn't really a HDV camera?
|
Absolutely not! The H1 will shine as an HDV camcorder, there are some other things going on with the HDV side of this camera that we haven't begun to talk about. And keep in mind that while I'm the one who has been consistently pushing the "not just HDV, but real HD" deal, that's not to take anything away from the HDV format. Remember,
it's me... I'm a huge proponent of HDV. You're looking at the biggest and oldest site on the net for HDV. No other web community comes close to the amount of traffic we get for HDV here. We're at well over 30,000 posts in our HDV section now, and it's still our fastest growing area.
Quote:
If a camera has a native recording format built in you kind of have to call it as that.
|
It is called that. Actually it's called an "HD Video Camera Recorder" if you look at the markings.
Quote:
The SONY F900 also has optional SDI ports but nobody calls that a camera head but a HDCAM camera. The Panasonic Varicam has 2 HD-SDI ports built in and it is still a DVCPROHD camera and not a camera head
|
Because that's how they're used... like I said, it all comes down to who buys it and what do they use it for.
Look, this is a moot topic really... getting back to the original question, why isn't this in the HDV forum, I have already answered that it will be, except the forum category won't be called "HDV" anymore. That's because the category will be the home of the P2 camera as well. It'll be something like "Affordable High Definition" or somesuch and it'll include the HVX200, the XL H1, the Sony and JVC cams as well... so that it doesn't matter if you look at the H1 as "just HDV" or "more than HDV," either way is good. It's all High Def in the long run, and it's more affordable now than it ever has been no matter what camera you choose (although I submit that "affordable" is a highly relative term).
If you ask me, I wish we could build our "Technique" areas up much more than our "Gear" areas anyway. That's where the real education should be, I know I'm never through learning about this stuff.