Great report, thanks!
heath |
Maybe they'll make it up by selling a 400.00 extended warranty
|
Quote:
heath |
Since I don't want to be responsible or putting Toshiba out of business, I won't buy one at all. I just don't want the guilt.:)
|
Ha ha ha ha!
hwm |
This format war is going to be very interesting to watch. Unlike VHS vs. Beta, this time around the studios have taken sides. With the first war, the studios released films on both formats. People just ended up getting screwed if they owned the wrong one in the end. Whereas now, the studios are taking sides. Does that mean you won't see Disney movies unlesss you own the right player or Universal films if you don't own the one they support? Are we going to see Sony Pictures release films on HD-DVD or only Blu-Ray?
Keep in mind that it is illegal for a company to make a dual-player that plays both. There's a provision in the Blu-Ray clause that says if you manufacture a Blu-Ray device, that device must not also play HD-DVD's. (Which is kind of ironic, since both formats use the same video codecs. Just the disc is different.) This makes me wonder where this war is going to take us... |
Daniel,
I imagine the one equalizer in this whole showdown will be the internet, i.e. Itunes and the like where you can already purchase movies online. I do imagine that most likely we will all watch things more and more from a none harddisk format. That's my two cents. Ofcourse, I'm not Bill Gates or Steven Speilburg. |
Quote:
|
Someone is, I don't know if it's Sanyo or LG (is that the right name?) or whom...
heath |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
So for digital distribution to really hit, we would need to do the following things: 1. Convince way, way more people to start downloading content. 2. Start offering much higher resolution videos. 3. Hope pepople have the bandwidth to support these resolutions. 4. Somehow integrate the TV with the computer. (This really has not happened yet, except maybe a handful of Mac Mini and Media Center users.) Seems like a task that, to me, is going to take much longer than sorting out this little format war of ours. Granted, digital distribution is something to watch, but I don't think it's going to be fully complete by a year or so from now. Whereas I think within a year or so from now, we'll probably have a feel for how the DVD market is doing. |
Quote:
So until one of the two HD disc formats becomes ubiquitous and affordable, I'd say as a consumer that what I can get from my cable company is more appealing and convenient than either of the disc-based options. Having seen this, I'm now skeptical that either disc-based format will catch on widely in the near future. |
HD Video On Demand isn't that hot IMO.
I can buy a HD DVD player or Blu-Ray and choose to rent my discs from Netflix or Blockbuster. Comcast charges $3.99-5.99 for movies in my area. Not a good deal compared to $17.99 all I can eat 3 out at a time Netflix HD. Both optical formats will look better than the HD crap streaming over cable lines and limited to 19.4Mbps. |
19.4 Mbps is for terrestrial broadcast DTV. The bitrate over Digital Cable and Satellite is often much lower - and has often gone through another generation of decode/encode.
And the terrestrial stuff is often lower due to bit stripped off for data, extra sub-channels and other overhead. For instance, the CBS station in my area sends out a stream of HD and an SD simulcast. Why do they waste the bits? All of the receivers I'm aware of can downsample from HD to SD. And then there's the quality of the real-time encoders. Some are quite good. Others, like the ones NBC used for the 2004 Olympics, are terrible. Watching the closeups of the backstrokers, you could see that they were swimming in square water, rather than the round drops that we get in the rest of the world. (!) No doubt, the quality of a good encode onto a Blu-ray disc played from a top player will far exceed the quality that you'll ever get from Cable. It's hard to get live sports from Netflix though... |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:39 AM. |
DV Info Net -- Real Names, Real People, Real Info!
1998-2024 The Digital Video Information Network