Just my speculation. This Ingest Box not fpga based.
Core is P4-M-552. It is correct, David?

David,

Since your testing the Canon... how long till we have a drive ready for that camera... hopefully around release time...

Thanks,

Gary

Correct, it is not FPGA based, but it is not Pentium-M based (too slow for 1920x1080 10-bit.)

I guess - but you can't digitise to it without the DnxHD board, so really it's only a post solution for programs like AfterFX etc (unless you have an Adrenaline or above with the HD board).

Still I understand your position.

So...no 24p for the HD100?

I'm pretty sure Dave answered that question in the following post.

"all the common frame rates" 24p I would say is a common frame rate. The only reason I asked him about 720 60p is that there seems to be some disagreement in this forum as to whether or not the HD100 supports that through the component out.

Yes to 24p and yes 60p.

Good to hear David. I doubt it will be cheap enough for me, but I look forward to an cheap attachable version one day for cheap HD cameras.

Wayne, what you think about "cheap attachable version" CFHD DVR 720p based on ETX-IM333 computer-on-module.
http://www.adlinktech.com/news/news_...ucts/n_121.htm

Bummer, I thought that was the whole point of the Wafian recorder. If it's just a non-portable box, how is that any different from building a computer with an HD-SDI card and capturing to any desired HD codec? A portable version would be much more significant, because it would offer a direct alternative to shooting with the Panasonic HVX200 using the matching Firestore drive for that camera.

I have to agree Kevin - no doubt it might be tricked up with some hardwired VTR style buttons, but at the end of the day if its just a miniPC... well you can't put it on your camera.

It is absolutely true that you can capture HDSDI feed into a PC for a similar effect, yet there are a lot of advantages for the Wafian recorder will have over self configured setups. It is a lot smaller than you average workstation, allowing for more imaginative applications; one of our customers is planning to place the unit in the trunk/boot of a car (for in car shoots) and control the unit wirelessly. The unit is a lot quieter than your average workstation as the CineForm compression can always store full res. HD to a single drive, large RAIDs are not needed; there are very few compressors that are both real-time and produce a small enough small enough output at the high quality we target, and be quiet enough to be on the set. Currently the only competitor in the same price range will be Prospect HD work stations, and we have customers currently and in the past, directly capturing to their Prospect systems. The Wafian makes that workflow easier, and much cheaper than a D5 or SR deck. Hopefully with the success of this product will allow units to get small and battery driven, and eventually totally portable for a wider range of shooting conditions.

You've got a point about portability (though the JVCHD100 is already portable with a portable HD codec in HDV. Further to this, the 720p24 mode of HDV codec is expected to perform as well if not better than the 720p24 mode of the DVCPRO-HD)

However, you're comparing:
1920x1080 and 1280x720 10-bit 4:2:2
to
1280x1080 and 960x720 8-bit 4:2:2 (or 2.67:1.33:1.33 and 3:1.5:1.5 compared ot the native resolution).

It's pretty easy to guess which will look better.

-Steve

If I needed live HD-SDI recording and couldn't get it in portable form, then I'd probably just build a workstation since I'd need that to do the editing anyway. Small size and low noise could be advantages for the Wafian recorder, but maybe not by much compared to hand-picking computer parts.

As far as competition is concerned, what about computer-based HD-SDI solutions using Avid, Apple or Canopus products? Even uncompressed HD capture isn't all that expensive these days, considering you can buy two terabytes of storage with a good SATA RAID card for under $1500. Once we remove portability from the discussion, there are a lot of options which could be considered.

Please, do not make this!:)
We must concentrate on portability.
CFHD highly optimised for pentium M and as David Newman have said: real time encoding 720p24 possible with laptop P4M760 based. Only need component or hd-sdi adapter/convertor for laptop like this PCMCIA: http://www.imperx.com/frame_grabbers...framelink.html
and capture software alike DV Rack.