Perrone Ford |
February 21st, 2009 09:21 PM |
All valid points Charles. So for the benefit of those who are wondering why I didn't choose those options, I'll explain:
1. I tried the RIFA bounced into white foamcore. Problem was that there simply wasn't enough light on the foamcore to give me enough fill. That was exactly what I was going for before I had to place a second light there, and forgo the hairlight. This setup was not my first choice.
2. Shiny board on a boom would have been great. But I have no boom in my kit and both c-stands that I have at my disposal were already being used. Lack of gear in this case limited options.
3. I could have taken some of the light off the back wall easily. I put it there. Decreasing the light behind her would have increased separation, but would also have stopped the effect I wanted where her face was not the brightest thing in camera. It was a tradeoff I had to make in this case. I wanted a daylight filled room but just couldn't get it. I thought of bouncing the light off a piece of foamcore, but simply ran out of time.
4. I also HATE the bookcase being centered behind her head. The space and angles in the room were dictated to me. I had furniture I simply could NOT move. It was a challenge just to get a clear path from the camera to the chair the talent was seated in.
This shoot is a classic example of trying to come up with a look, then having to improvise on set because of limitations. In this case there were limitations of power, room, and gear. I did the best I could to get a pleasing look with the tools I had at my disposal. Charles' comments are spot on, and with different gear, or better options, I would have incorporated every one of them.
Thanks for your comments, and I am sure they will help others who have a chance to read them.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Charles Papert
(Post 1016044)
You could have achieved a nice effect with just one of those sources (probably the Rifa and a bounce board positioned close to the down side of her face, angled back to pick up the Rifa, and had all that power left for your hairlight. Or, hung a bit of shiny board on a boom behind her head to bounce back some of the key onto her hair for a nice soft edge.
With a bit of flagging you could have kept the exposure a bit more down on the back wall, which would have helped separate as well--and I personally don't like the bookcase being centered directly behind her, it might have been nice to split the frame somewhat with it.
that's my 1/50 of a dollar.
|
|