Video to Film transfer question
I read an article in the recent issue of Movie Maker magazine which states that it is impossible to transfer a video footage to film if the video was shot in 30 fps frame mode. Also it says to keep your shutter no higher than 1/60.
I have a hard time believing that video shot in progressive mode cannot be transfered to film. Can anyone help me understand this one? Thanks in advance. |
There's also a film look article which covers what to do with DV ---> film transfers at dv.com - every transfer house has a set of guidelines to go with.
|
"recent issue of Movie Maker magazine which states that it is impossible to transfer a video footage to film if the video was shot in 30 fps frame mode. Also it says to keep your shutter no higher than 1/60. "
based on above the article is WRONG - for PAL = no problems .. for NTSC = problems -it does transfer but not very well ... the more motion/movement in progressive/frame mode the worse the artitacts ( look at movie "somebody" shot NTSC frame mode transferred to 35mm - notice when persons isn't moving much it's OK but when persons moves alot artifact all over the edges) ... frame mode has a rez loss of approx 25-30% over interlace more compared to PROGRESSIVE ... anything over 1/60 shutter should be used for EFFECT use ( look at "28 days" where they used hi shutter for effect shot on PAL XL in frame mode) look for a transfer house that may have written speacial software for 30p ... if one can write software to fill ( create new frames based on frame before and frame after) in frames for bullet, matrix type , slo-mo type effects then one can write software to analyze 30p taken down to 24fps .... |
Thanks, I knew there had to be a way since many people out there shoot progressive with cameras such as XL1. Limiting film transfer only to videos done in interlaced mode seemed wrong.
|
XL1 projects that are transferred to film are originated on PAL cameras, at 25fps. As of the last time I checked, it is basically impossible to get a quality transfer done from material that originated at 30p.
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:46 PM. |
DV Info Net -- Real Names, Real People, Real Info!
1998-2024 The Digital Video Information Network