View Full Version : Camera Bags


Matt Setnes
August 22nd, 2006, 12:47 PM
I put off getting one mostly because I was waiting for Petrol's backpack version.

So for there are a total of 6 bags from 3 dffierent vendors to choose from, there are more, but these seem to be the best of what I gathered.

Petrol PCBP-2
Petrol PCUB-HD
Porta Brace CTC-2
Porta Brace HK-P3
Kata BP-502
Kata CCC-10

Any input on any of these?

Tim Brown
August 22nd, 2006, 12:55 PM
I'm very fond of the CCC-10. I find it to be roomy and can accommodate my tripod plate and camera with Anton Bauer battery plus a few extras.

A key selling point with Kata and their bags are the yellow interior which makes it easier to find smaller items within the bag. You never really appreciate this feature until you actually put the bag in use. Very helpful feature, well thought out and a very well-built bag. Of course the Petrol bags have an orange interior for the same reason and I like their bag build quality as well. I just don't have any experience with any of those bags listed.

K. Forman
August 22nd, 2006, 01:01 PM
I can't recommend any of those, but I can NOT recommend a Sima. I bought a pair of these a couple years ago, for my XL1s and GL1. I got rid of the XL, and got a rolling tool box that worked perfect for the GL. Now that I have the HD100, it wouldn't fit the tool box, so I dusted off the Sima. During our week at Disney, it decided to open up a downpour. While the camera didn't get soaked, the bag itself was rather moist. But, the price was great ;)

As far as deals go, I think B&H has a package deal, buy a bag, get a white balance card and a rain jacket free. I so need one of those!

Drew Curran
August 22nd, 2006, 01:04 PM
I'm very fond of the CCC-10. I find it to be roomy and can accommodate my tripod plate and camera with Anton Bauer battery plus a few extras.

Yes it holds the camera with all this attached, but I find it to be too small width wise. I have to unplug the mic XLR plug before placing the camera in the bag as there is some stress on it otherwise. A right-angled xlr plug would solve this. I also notice that it bends/flexes the EVF when the zip is closed. There are pouches at either end that will hold a items like batteries, but not much else.

I wouldn't recommend this bag unless you want a very 'snug' fit.

If Kata do a larger bag I would get it instead. I believe Portabrace do larger bags, as do Petrol.

Andrew

Tim Brown
August 22nd, 2006, 01:13 PM
Yes it holds the camera with all this attached, but I find it to be too small width wise. I have to unplug the mic XLR plug before placing the camera in the bag as there is some stress on it otherwise. A right-angled xlr plug would solve this. I also notice that it bends/flexes the EVF when the zip is closed. There are pouches at either end that will hold a items like batteries, but not much else.

I wouldn't recommend this bag unless you want a very 'snug' fit.

If Kata do a larger bag I would get it instead. Portabrace do larger bags, as do Petrol.

Andrew

I know what you mean Drew, but I've found that if you tilt it a bit you can usually wiggle it in without too much difficulty.

I think that most of these bags have a tendency to be snug as our Petrol PCCB-2-N that says that it's designed for the XL1 & 2, but we have to squeeze and stretch to get our H1 into the bag. It has a much tighter fit than the HD100 in the Kata bag. Unfortunately I think the smaller sizing is on purpose as to not "slosh" the camera around during transport, but if anyone else knows more, I'd hope they would chime in.

Drew Curran
August 22nd, 2006, 01:48 PM
Tim

I have a feeling that if the bag got a firm knock with the camera in it, the EVF would break off. Whilst the bag is tough, it does tend to bend in the middle. I even removed the shoulder strap as the bag would bend around my body. I always carry it with the handles.

You are probably right about the snug fit being so the camera doesn't slosh about, but some EVF protection would be great. A more rigid side that didn't flex.

Andrew

Daniel Weber
August 22nd, 2006, 02:17 PM
I have the Petrol PCUB-HD bag. The camera fits real nice, their is even a section that bulges out a little for the VF to fit into. This part also has plastic lining the inside to provide more protection for the VF.

I can fit the camea in with my IDX battery attached as well.

There are pockets for tapes, filters, etc. I wouldn't have this bag be my only mode of transport for a shoot though.

I always carry a run bag with extra batteries, tapes, cords, mics, etc.

I found that the Petro bag was the best option for the money. It is also small enough to fit into an airline overhead bin, which is a big plus for me.

Dan Weber

Jack Walker
August 22nd, 2006, 02:23 PM
I found that the Petro bag was the best option for the money. It is also small enough to fit into an airline overhead bin, which is a big plus for me.
However, carry-on baggage is no longer allowed, is it? Isn't a hard case necessary now for air travel so it can be checked?

Daniel Weber
August 22nd, 2006, 02:35 PM
However, carry-on baggage is no longer allowed, is it? Isn't a hard case necessary now for air travel so it can be checked?

Jack,

As far as I know you can still carry on board a plane. It was only the flights to and from the UK that had the restrictions. I believe that they have been slightly lifted for those flights.

I will check it out since I have a trip to Egypt next week and I was going to carry on a camera.

Dan Weber

Henrik Helms
August 23rd, 2006, 10:57 AM
I like the bag very much. I do a lot of documentaries - and it is easy to carry around. It fits the HD100 with the wideanglelens mounted - microport can stay on top of the camera and the extra cameramic stays also on when the camera is in the bag. The Kata bag has a extra opening to get the camera out quickly. Here the JVC is to big to get out.
Another downside is the yellow colour inside the bag - it easily gets dirty...

Sam Miller
August 23rd, 2006, 12:08 PM
While on a July shoot in Memphis the PortaBrace CTC-2 was protective and spacious. It held the HD100 fitted with wideangle adapter and Anton Bauer Dionic 90 battery pack. Also I was able to pack the charger inside.

Sam

Justin Deming
August 23rd, 2006, 12:25 PM
This thread came at a great time. I was looking for a bag too, I think the Petrol PCUB-HD looks like the better bag for me.

It comes with a rain cover, but that cover may not work for an HD-100. I'll test it & find out though.

K. Forman
August 23rd, 2006, 12:40 PM
Justin- When you are ready to order your bag and slick, call them first. Ask if the bag and slicker will work with the HD100, it may not fit, and they might have a set up that will.

Shai Camerini
August 23rd, 2006, 01:54 PM
I put off getting one mostly because I was waiting for Petrol's backpack version.

So for there are a total of 6 bags from 3 dffierent vendors to choose from, there are more, but these seem to be the best of what I gathered.

Petrol PCBP-2
Petrol PCUB-HD
Porta Brace CTC-2
Porta Brace HK-P3
Kata BP-502
Kata CCC-10

Any input on any of these?

I tested the Petrol bags the PCBP-2 is huge, way to big for this small size camera.
and the PCUB-HD may be comfortable for the camera, but not for the operator.

Matt Setnes
August 23rd, 2006, 02:11 PM
that's why I was trying to gather the most of what everyone uses. The PCUB-HD looks like the right bag for me, but I'm thinking of getting the Kata BP-502 instead for easy hauling

Shai Camerini
August 23rd, 2006, 02:37 PM
try the KATA HB-207 I talked to a KATA service person and she recommended that bag for a HD100 with AB power kit

William Hohauser
August 23rd, 2006, 02:46 PM
I put off getting one mostly because I was waiting for Petrol's backpack version.

So for there are a total of 6 bags from 3 dffierent vendors to choose from, there are more, but these seem to be the best of what I gathered.

Petrol PCBP-2
Petrol PCUB-HD
Porta Brace CTC-2
Porta Brace HK-P3
Kata BP-502
Kata CCC-10

Any input on any of these?

Depending on the type of filming you intend to do, I would consider adding the Porta Brace CC-325-P Quick-Draw Camera Case to the list. It offers a substantial degree of sturdiness over standard soft cases.

I have a previous version of it for my HD-100. While the bag adds to the carry weight cosiderably (it is reinforced with plastic and metal to protect the camera especially the viewfinder), I feel the protection offered is well worth the price. The soft cases wil not prevent a viewfinder catastrophe and I've seen them with rental HD-100s.

The case I have has enough room to store at least 10 tapes, the IDX battery, the battery charger, the AC adapter, microphones, cables and various small things like headphones and lens cleaning kits. I'm sure I'll figure out a place to squeeze in the FireStore that shows up on Friday. The only drawback is that I have to unplug the on-camera microphone as the cord is pressed against the side. Anybody know a place to get a right-angle XLR adapter? Markertek no longer carries them.

The version now listed on Porta-Brace seems to be shaped differently so I can't vouch that it has as much room.

Matt Setnes
August 23rd, 2006, 04:24 PM
try the KATA HB-207 I talked to a KATA service person and she recommended that bag for a HD100 with AB power kit

I believe this bag is for photography cameras. 22.4 inches. I'm not sure. How long is the HD100 + the AB power kit?

Shai Camerini
August 23rd, 2006, 11:21 PM
Mine (with an extremely wide battery) coms to 22" while the KATA BP-502 is only 21.3", and the KATA HB-207 is actually longer 22.4"
in centimeters it sounds better :-)

Eric Darling
August 23rd, 2006, 11:45 PM
I own the Petrol PCUB-HD and use it with the HD100. It's a good bag, all around, although it's a little too snug for this camera if you keep stuff in the large outer pocket (I've been carrying some warm cards and the manual in there while I get used to using this camera). Everything is pretty good, except I've noticed that it's so snug that the gain switch on the camera gets engaged into the H position almost every time the camera is removed from the case. That's a major problem since it's very hard to see gain in HD modes - we actually spent about 10 minutes on a shoot the first time it happened trying to figure out why we couldn't get the picture exposed - it was way over.

Furthermore, if you use this case, you NEED to remove the XLR cable for the shotgun mic. They should have made this an elbow connector for this very reason. But, hey, a cheap mic is a cheap mic, I guess.

Shai Camerini
August 24th, 2006, 12:20 PM
I went and bought the KATA BP-502, i really believe its the best bag for this camera
Its very large yet hold the camera firmly and it has a lot of pockets for accessories

The downside is that when when unpacking you have to lay it on the backpack system directly and then it will get dirty...

K. Forman
August 24th, 2006, 12:31 PM
I usually lay a small hand towel over the camera before closing the bag. This adds a little more padding, as well as a clean soft surface for setting up the cam. It also comes in handy for wiping the sweat out of your eyes.

Matt Setnes
August 24th, 2006, 12:51 PM
...given the fact the KATA HB-207 isn't for the jvc. The biggest dimension you read is the width of the bag, so it'd be very wide on the back. That's good though, I think I've made my choice on the BP-502 as well. My guess is i wouldn't have the xlr problem either. Where did you buy your bag from Camerini?

Shai Camerini
August 24th, 2006, 01:31 PM
It's in Israel... :-)

Brian Luce
August 25th, 2006, 05:27 AM
I'm wondering with all these new restriction if it's best to go with hard shell pelican style cases.

and if one goes that route, might it be wiser to detach the VF? there are two reasons i can think of:

1) vf has been determined as a weak link, many breakage issues. Detaching it will reduce chance of injury.

2) you can use a smaller case if you detach the VF.