Considering AVCHD

Bill Pryor · December 25th, 2008, 02:06 PM

It's interesting that a client would request a format. You can get AVCHD from a camera with a 1/6" chip up to a camera with three 1/3" chips, from a hand held point-and-shoot with no adjustment, up to a professional camera. That's like requesting that something be shot in HDV, or in Betacam or DVCAM. What camera is used, what lens it has, etc., makes a lot more difference than the format. And even in the AVCHD consumer cameras, you can go from 9mbs up to Canon's HF11 with 24mbs. A big difference there. The Panasonic 150 is a hell of a lot different than the Flip Mino HD. And, other than that one Panasonic offering, at this time I believe all the AVCHD cameras are single chip consumer cameras ranging from 1/6" to slightly less than 1/3" chips. Unless your client specifically mentioned the 150, he is requesting that you use a single chip consumer camera. I find that odd.

Steve Wolla · December 27th, 2008, 11:24 AM

Hopefully Panasonic being the only one with a truly professional AVCHD cam will change sooner rather than later. It's a great cam hope that Canon and Sony are paying attention here.

I am currently transcoding my files to DVCProHD via the Transcoder download from Panasonic. Then I just dump the DVCProHD files on the timeline and go to town. It works quite well, but may not support non-Panasonic cams.

I see where Adobe is claiming AVCHD support in CS4, but no 720p yet....will look again at it early in '09. For now transcoding works OK.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

December 25th, 2008, 02:06 PM	#16
Bill Pryor Contributor Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Kansas City, MO Posts: 4,449	It's interesting that a client would request a format. You can get AVCHD from a camera with a 1/6" chip up to a camera with three 1/3" chips, from a hand held point-and-shoot with no adjustment, up to a professional camera. That's like requesting that something be shot in HDV, or in Betacam or DVCAM. What camera is used, what lens it has, etc., makes a lot more difference than the format. And even in the AVCHD consumer cameras, you can go from 9mbs up to Canon's HF11 with 24mbs. A big difference there. The Panasonic 150 is a hell of a lot different than the Flip Mino HD. And, other than that one Panasonic offering, at this time I believe all the AVCHD cameras are single chip consumer cameras ranging from 1/6" to slightly less than 1/3" chips. Unless your client specifically mentioned the 150, he is requesting that you use a single chip consumer camera. I find that odd.

December 27th, 2008, 11:24 AM	#17
Steve Wolla Major Player Join Date: Nov 2005 Posts: 477	Hopefully Panasonic being the only one with a truly professional AVCHD cam will change sooner rather than later. It's a great cam hope that Canon and Sony are paying attention here. I am currently transcoding my files to DVCProHD via the Transcoder download from Panasonic. Then I just dump the DVCProHD files on the timeline and go to town. It works quite well, but may not support non-Panasonic cams. I see where Adobe is claiming AVCHD support in CS4, but no 720p yet....will look again at it early in '09. For now transcoding works OK.