T2i recording has "been stopped automatically"
 

First post. I've already learned enough to invest in this camera and in a good card. I've had the camera three weeks now. For the past week, I'm getting the "recording has been stopped automatically" error about every eight or nine clips. My confusion is that I bought a high end card (ProMaster class 10, 32gb) which I thought was supposed to avoid this issue. Is it still most likely the card's fault? Could it be an issue with the camera itself? Thanks.

you know it stops after 12minutes (=4GB) of continuous recording, right?
I am not exactly following when you said "about every eight or nine clips"?
how do you count "clips"?
please specify more, so we can help you.

JJ

It's definitely not making it to the limit. It stops randomly anywhere from 5 seconds to a minute into the recording. I'll see the buffering gauge and the recording stops. It won't happen again for a few clips, but inevitably comes back. I'm probably just going to take the card back. Would it have anything to do with the fact that it's 32gb? Or that it's ProMaster?

Take the card back, its not cutting it. Get a Sandisk or Transcend. I have been using Transcend class 6 and more lately class 10 cards in my EX1 for a year, and more recently in my 550D, they have never missed a beat. The class 10 are also about the same price as class 6.

A lot of people suggest to just stick to 8gb cards to prevent over-heating.

That happened to me also with Delkin 16 and 32 GB card, after recording few minutes only then it works fine after that, I just turned it off wait a few minutes and back shooting again.

The size of the card wont make an ounce of difference to overheating.

But that shouldn't happen, its another case of the card not being up to the job. A good card will record one continous clip, right up to the 12 minute limit, if you have to stop and start every few minutes the card is clearly not up to it.

Colin, there is nothing wrong with the card, It is a class 6 Delkin card, I used it many times with no problems, but every once in a while the camera just shuts down with no reason at all.
I do have the battery grip to help with the overheating problem, but I don't think that really made any difference, the camera does overheat often especially when you shoot at 60fps.

Delkin is not a "first class" media, rather in the "bargain" media class.

SanDisk, while not very "bargain" priced does seem to give value performance. While Transcend is not as bad and many swear "by" it as having delivered trouble free performance, I've seen just enough in the way of "tales of woe" from these that cause me to avoid it.

I see the least amount of complaints of card failure or card error from SanDisk so that's all I trust now.

I pay the price and roll on.

So where does ProMaster fit in to the spectrum? It's the only 32gb stocked locally (and I leave on a trip in 10 days), and they'll likely just offer me an identical replacement. Should I accept it, or should I order the SanDisk ASAP?

Exactly, Trust to the better known, proven brands. As I have said many times before, find a card that you find reliable, and stick with it. Promaster is being touted by a few outlets, over Sandisk, Transcend etc, but those selling it often dont have a clue on the requirments of a card being used to record video. I had never heard of Promaster until I read another thread on it a few weeks ago. It may be a fine card, but not one I would trust in my cams.

I have a Toshiba 4Gb SDHC card which works perfectly, yet it cost twice ($100) as other card I have of 16Gb ($50). Both are class 6 yet the 16Gb cannot handle the T2i's video recording bitrate; but good for pictures and other less intensive works.

It is possible that these manufacturers are not really lying "per se". They are probably measuring the sustained speeds at different time lengths so you see how two class 6 cards could sustain their rated speed for longer or shorter time, thus making them both to pass the rating yet in real life behave differently.

I am not going to search now but perhaps there is a minimum time such card has to sustain certain speed to be rated class 6.

In the end you get what you pay for.

Another vote for the SanDisk cards. I've got 8Gb Class 10's and one (gasp!) Class 4 SanDisk 8Gb that run just fine recording video in my T2i.

Don't skimp on the cards!!! It's only the part that's saving your video, right? :)

yikes
 

i just had this message too - totally out of the blue. Luckily I was just fiddling around and wasn't on a job. It happened on my 16gb Sandisk extreme class 10 card (totally legit), so it's definitely not a crappy card issue. It appear about 3 seconds into recording - never happened before (thats from extensive field use), hope it doesn't happen again!

Does anyone know the actual reason why it does this?

ProMaster is rebranded if i am not mistaken. the only brand ive used for video problem free is SanDisk cards, not to say certain brand cards of certain size and speeds dont work, but all the sandisks ive tested, SD and CF, work fine.

I get that msg frequently. Almost always just after I boot the camera and push record. I just push it again and it rolls fine. So far, its never happened during a take. Unless it's getting in the way of your video-making, I wouldn't worry too much!

BTW, I use the cheapest class 6 cards I can find. Seems fine apart from this very small inconvenience.

I feel that way as well... of course, I'm not paying SAG rates on most shoots. When I do, I pony up the expensive cards.

happened to me
 

This happened to me just yesterday for the first time. The problem, in my case, was that I switched from jpeg to RAW accidently. I use a lot of manual lenses so I take a snapshot in movie mode before I shoot video to make sure settings are what I want. Apparently, shooting RAW (snapshot) then immediatly pressing record for video is more than my Transcend 16gig class 10 could handle.

I got that message once on a Delkin 32gig and it killed all the footage. Threw that card on the shelf with a big "X" on it and never saw that message again whether 32gig, 16gig, Delkin or Sandisk. Convinced that was a bad card issue.
I think you're asking for trouble if you continue getting that message on the same card.

Re: T2i recording has "been stopped automatically"
 

We were having that same problem and it appears to be the recording bit-rate that is screwing up the shooting; change to a slower speed might help...good luck---


Ted Lewis
BNN-TV

Re: T2i recording has "been stopped automatically"
 

I'm surprised no one has mentioned formatting the card. I format after each time I transfer the footage and put the card back into the camera, or if I move the card from the 60D to the 5D lll. I only used Hoodman and SanDisk cards. No problems.

Re: T2i recording has "been stopped automatically"
 

correct; the error can and will happen to any card if formatted on a PC with different specs from internal formatting, and also especially if not formatted (low level) in camera with magic lantern. it wont ALWAYS happen, but it will NOT happen if formatted in camera, then ML is reapplied. pain, but works. i use all SanDisk Class 10 8GB's.

Re: T2i recording has "been stopped automatically"
 

I just started using my 60D and learned today that it also stops after 12 minutes no matter what card I use. Is this just the limit for these cameras?
Thanks
Art

Re: T2i recording has "been stopped automatically"
 

in HD yes, about 12 minutes.