HD TV necessary? at DVinfo.net

Dennis Stevens · June 11th, 2006, 08:45 AM

I'm this has come up before, but a search didn't precisely answer this question.... sorry if I'm being redundant.

Got my new jvc hd100u, and now I'm trying to see what other pieces what help me get the most out of it.

I have a Dell 2005fpw monitor... I'm wondering if I should get an HD TV, just a 23" inch one, to get a better idea of what it'll look like? Would that be any more accurate that just using my monitor?

Dennis Stevens · June 11th, 2006, 01:56 PM

Just wanted to add, I wasn't looking for a discussion of different monitors and their relative merits... I found lots of threads, which are really helpful. I think my question is a little different.

Also, I'm thinking about getting jvc's hd dvd player..... Also, to help me gauge how my stuff would look. Also, I have this crazy idea of showing my films in art galleries, kind of the way they have folk singers and performance pieces. These happen a lot in my area, I was thinking of renting a big screen hdtv, hd dvd player, then you charge admission like a coffeehouse/performance piece... A digital version of the travelling village roadshow.

David Kennett · June 12th, 2006, 10:10 AM

Dennis,

I bought a JVC HD10 when it was brand new, and it took me about three months to break down and buy a 50" Samsung DLP HD set. I even took the camcorder down to the local BB, where they allowed me to show my footage.

I monitor my editing on a 19" Viewsonic CRT. During editing I use a smaller window, but regularly view my handiwork full screen in 1280x960 res. (for 720p full hor res). This is NOT adequate. The 50" screen shows things I did not see on the 19". It's not that the 19" doesn't show things - it's that I don't SEE things.

There is something totally different about the large high definition image! You become aware of the importance of rock-steady wide angle shots. Longer shot times become more appropriate. The Imax films available on INHD or Discovery HD can provide many examples appropriate for HDTV. In fact, I'm surprised there aren't more comments showing up about how different techniques can take advantage of a larger, sharper image.

You might find a front projector could help you evaluate your material, as well as providing a portable display.

The big screen experience is definitely DIFFERENT!

June 11th, 2006, 08:45 AM	#1
Dennis Stevens Major Player Join Date: May 2006 Location: Boston, Massachusetts Posts: 425	HD TV necessary? I'm this has come up before, but a search didn't precisely answer this question.... sorry if I'm being redundant. Got my new jvc hd100u, and now I'm trying to see what other pieces what help me get the most out of it. I have a Dell 2005fpw monitor... I'm wondering if I should get an HD TV, just a 23" inch one, to get a better idea of what it'll look like? Would that be any more accurate that just using my monitor?

June 11th, 2006, 01:56 PM	#2
Dennis Stevens Major Player Join Date: May 2006 Location: Boston, Massachusetts Posts: 425	Reply and addendum to my own dumba$$ question Just wanted to add, I wasn't looking for a discussion of different monitors and their relative merits... I found lots of threads, which are really helpful. I think my question is a little different. Also, I'm thinking about getting jvc's hd dvd player..... Also, to help me gauge how my stuff would look. Also, I have this crazy idea of showing my films in art galleries, kind of the way they have folk singers and performance pieces. These happen a lot in my area, I was thinking of renting a big screen hdtv, hd dvd player, then you charge admission like a coffeehouse/performance piece... A digital version of the travelling village roadshow.

June 12th, 2006, 10:10 AM	#3
David Kennett Major Player Join Date: Jul 2003 Location: North Ridgeville, Ohio Posts: 407	Dennis, I bought a JVC HD10 when it was brand new, and it took me about three months to break down and buy a 50" Samsung DLP HD set. I even took the camcorder down to the local BB, where they allowed me to show my footage. I monitor my editing on a 19" Viewsonic CRT. During editing I use a smaller window, but regularly view my handiwork full screen in 1280x960 res. (for 720p full hor res). This is NOT adequate. The 50" screen shows things I did not see on the 19". It's not that the 19" doesn't show things - it's that I don't SEE things. There is something totally different about the large high definition image! You become aware of the importance of rock-steady wide angle shots. Longer shot times become more appropriate. The Imax films available on INHD or Discovery HD can provide many examples appropriate for HDTV. In fact, I'm surprised there aren't more comments showing up about how different techniques can take advantage of a larger, sharper image. You might find a front projector could help you evaluate your material, as well as providing a portable display. The big screen experience is definitely DIFFERENT! __________________ Dave