Editing DVCPROHD footage vs HDV at DVinfo.net

Daniel Cegla · December 19th, 2006, 05:53 AM

What kind of hardware does it take to effectively edit DVCPROHD footage vs HDV footage? Is DVCPROHD more or less demanding than HDV, and what kind of size requirements does each have in comparison to the other?

When streamed/imported from camera, what format is each type of footage in? (ie does HDV get stored as MPEG2 files & DVCPROHD as .AVI files, or...?)

Daniel Cegla · January 10th, 2007, 02:30 PM

bump.

I never got a response to this and it would be greatly appreciated.

How demanding is DVCPROHD footage on a computer and what do I need to effectively edit it?

Jason Ramsey · January 10th, 2007, 03:21 PM

HDV will be much more demanding on your pc than DVCPRO HD.

Users have reported editing DVCPRO HD on a not so new single core laptop. And, being able to do it in realtime right off of the card.

I use a core duo laptop and can edit 4-5 streams (probably more) in realtime (This being with EDIUS)

HDV = More demand on pc to edit due to its long format.

DVCPRO HD = you will need a lot more HDD space to store and archive your footage. 1080p is a gig a minute to record. 720pn is dependent on the frame rate, since it only records the amount of frames you tell it to. for 24fps in 720pn you will get about 2 and a half times that. On 16 gig cards I can record 41 minutes of 720p/24pn.

But DVCPRO HD is much less taxing on your system. Just not the amount of HDD space you will need to store, edit, archive it.

Jason

December 19th, 2006, 05:53 AM	#1
Daniel Cegla Regular Crew Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Portland, Oregon Posts: 57	Editing DVCPROHD footage vs HDV What kind of hardware does it take to effectively edit DVCPROHD footage vs HDV footage? Is DVCPROHD more or less demanding than HDV, and what kind of size requirements does each have in comparison to the other? When streamed/imported from camera, what format is each type of footage in? (ie does HDV get stored as MPEG2 files & DVCPROHD as .AVI files, or...?)

January 10th, 2007, 02:30 PM	#2
Daniel Cegla Regular Crew Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Portland, Oregon Posts: 57	bump. I never got a response to this and it would be greatly appreciated. How demanding is DVCPROHD footage on a computer and what do I need to effectively edit it?

January 10th, 2007, 03:21 PM	#3
Jason Ramsey RED / Scarlet / DVXUser Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Colorado Posts: 29	HDV will be much more demanding on your pc than DVCPRO HD. Users have reported editing DVCPRO HD on a not so new single core laptop. And, being able to do it in realtime right off of the card. I use a core duo laptop and can edit 4-5 streams (probably more) in realtime (This being with EDIUS) HDV = More demand on pc to edit due to its long format. DVCPRO HD = you will need a lot more HDD space to store and archive your footage. 1080p is a gig a minute to record. 720pn is dependent on the frame rate, since it only records the amount of frames you tell it to. for 24fps in 720pn you will get about 2 and a half times that. On 16 gig cards I can record 41 minutes of 720p/24pn. But DVCPRO HD is much less taxing on your system. Just not the amount of HDD space you will need to store, edit, archive it. Jason