Is the Marshall V-R70P-HDA really "HD?" at DVinfo.net

James Gleason · April 4th, 2006, 10:51 AM

I've searched through these forums for the past few weeks and although there are a lot of user contributions about this monitor, my questions is simple (I think): how can a monitor that has a resolution of 800x480 be considered "HD?"

I've seen this monitor at a trade show and was impressed with it's color and luminance, but does it really work as a viable "HD" monitor? Is it a trade off because it's a "field" monitor and not the 17+inches that a 1080p or 720p monitor can deliver?

I just received by HVX200 and am in the market for a field/studio monitor. Does this one "really" suffice? Or should you use this one in the field and a much larger one in the studio? Right now I can't afford both.
Even the upcoming 8.4 inch version is only 800x600 pixals and that is becuase it's a 4:3 native monitor, vs. the 16:9 native of the 7 inch.

Questions...answer?

Steev Dinkins · April 4th, 2006, 12:37 PM

It's an HD monitor in terms of being able to accept a real HD signal and use high quality scaling to it's native 800x480 res. If you look at the difference between HD component into this monitor vs any of the older crappy 7" Standard Def LCDs, you're eyes will feel like you've washed a coat of jello off of them.

If you have the HVX200, you want this monitor OR better.

James Gleason · April 4th, 2006, 02:20 PM

Thanks, Steev,

That's a good word. Do you feel that this monitor would double as a studio monitor as well? I'm not expecting it perform like a $4-5,000 HD monitor, but if it's more than capable as a dual use HD monitor, I'll go out and get it.

Also, I can't understand the manual's words on component out. Does the HVX200 NOT send a component signal out when it's hooked up via firewire? Is it simply a menu item to select? This camera is very deep and I'm just beginning to scratch the surface.

Steev Dinkins · April 4th, 2006, 02:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by James Gleason

Do you feel that this monitor would double as a studio monitor as well?

I think you may be dissapointed with it as a studio monitor.

Quote:

Originally Posted by James Gleason

Does the HVX200 NOT send a component signal out when it's hooked up via firewire? Is it simply a menu item to select? This camera is very deep and I'm just beginning to scratch the surface.

Hmmm. I'll have to double check, but I don't see any reason why you couldn't monitor out the D-terminal while also capturing via firewire. I'm assuming that's what you're wanting to do.

I simply set the D-terminal to always output 1080i. It's what looks the best into the Marshall.

Barry Green · April 4th, 2006, 03:07 PM

No, component output is disabled when using HD firewire input. No pass-thru component monitoring when HD firewire inputting.

James Gleason · April 4th, 2006, 05:23 PM

Thanks, Barry. I was afraid of that. "That's why I couldn't figure it out." What are you using for a firewire output to HD monitoring situation? AJA, Blackmagic? I'm using a MacBookPro for my editing and want to make sure I can monitor HD.

April 4th, 2006, 10:51 AM	#1
James Gleason Regular Crew Join Date: May 2003 Location: Hillsboro, OR Posts: 39	Is the Marshall V-R70P-HDA really "HD?" I've searched through these forums for the past few weeks and although there are a lot of user contributions about this monitor, my questions is simple (I think): how can a monitor that has a resolution of 800x480 be considered "HD?" I've seen this monitor at a trade show and was impressed with it's color and luminance, but does it really work as a viable "HD" monitor? Is it a trade off because it's a "field" monitor and not the 17+inches that a 1080p or 720p monitor can deliver? I just received by HVX200 and am in the market for a field/studio monitor. Does this one "really" suffice? Or should you use this one in the field and a much larger one in the studio? Right now I can't afford both. Even the upcoming 8.4 inch version is only 800x600 pixals and that is becuase it's a 4:3 native monitor, vs. the 16:9 native of the 7 inch. Questions...answer?

April 4th, 2006, 12:37 PM	#2
Steev Dinkins Major Player Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: San Francisco, CA Posts: 613	It's an HD monitor in terms of being able to accept a real HD signal and use high quality scaling to it's native 800x480 res. If you look at the difference between HD component into this monitor vs any of the older crappy 7" Standard Def LCDs, you're eyes will feel like you've washed a coat of jello off of them. If you have the HVX200, you want this monitor OR better. __________________ www.holyzoo.com

April 4th, 2006, 02:20 PM	#3
James Gleason Regular Crew Join Date: May 2003 Location: Hillsboro, OR Posts: 39	Thanks, Steev, That's a good word. Do you feel that this monitor would double as a studio monitor as well? I'm not expecting it perform like a $4-5,000 HD monitor, but if it's more than capable as a dual use HD monitor, I'll go out and get it. Also, I can't understand the manual's words on component out. Does the HVX200 NOT send a component signal out when it's hooked up via firewire? Is it simply a menu item to select? This camera is very deep and I'm just beginning to scratch the surface.

April 4th, 2006, 03:07 PM	#5
Barry Green Barry Wan Kenobi Join Date: Jul 2003 Location: North Carolina Posts: 3,863	No, component output is disabled when using HD firewire input. No pass-thru component monitoring when HD firewire inputting.

April 4th, 2006, 05:23 PM	#6
James Gleason Regular Crew Join Date: May 2003 Location: Hillsboro, OR Posts: 39	Thanks, Barry. I was afraid of that. "That's why I couldn't figure it out." What are you using for a firewire output to HD monitoring situation? AJA, Blackmagic? I'm using a MacBookPro for my editing and want to make sure I can monitor HD.