DV Info Net

DV Info Net (https://www.dvinfo.net/forum/)
-   What Happens in Vegas... (https://www.dvinfo.net/forum/what-happens-vegas/)
-   -   Any Core I7 users yet? (https://www.dvinfo.net/forum/what-happens-vegas/138334-any-core-i7-users-yet.html)

Alastair Brown November 24th, 2008 03:32 AM

Any Core I7 users yet?
 
Curious as to whether we have any Intel Core I7 users yet?

If we do, how are you finding your preview is compared to your old system.

Terry Esslinger November 24th, 2008 11:08 AM

I am a little confusedf. Does core I7 come in both dual and quad configurations?

Michael Wisniewski November 24th, 2008 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Terry Esslinger (Post 968278)
I am a little confusedf. Does core I7 come in both dual and quad configurations?

The current Intel® Core™ i7 chips are quad core only.

Bill Warshaw November 27th, 2008 03:58 PM

Very Impressed
 
I just built a Core i7 system with 3gb RAM and the 2.6 ghz processor. I had a 945D Dual Core with 4gb previously.

I am encoding VBR 2 pass SD DVD using TMPGenc frameserved from Vegas and Premier Pro CS3 with the Video Noise Reduction filter in TMPGenc enabled. Source is 1440x1080 HDV.

On my old system it would take around 11 hrs to encode 90 Mins of video.

Core i7 did it in under 2hrs with same settings. Not too shabby!!!

/billw

Alastair Brown November 27th, 2008 04:03 PM

Thats pretty darn impressive!

Jonathan Gentry December 1st, 2008 10:14 PM

Excellent Machine
 
Just built an i7 machine. Motherboard is the Asus P6T deluxe with the 920 (2.66ghz) entry level chip. 6GB of Patriot 1333 memory. Using stock cooling. Overclocked the processor to 3.8Ghz and runs perfectly stable at 100% load for hours.

Machine is very very fast. I'll let you know how renders compare to my Q6600 Quad core chip as soon as I have time.

Alastair Brown December 2nd, 2008 01:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jonathan Gentry (Post 971511)
Just built an i7 machine. Motherboard is the Asus P6T deluxe with the 920 (2.66ghz) entry level chip. 6GB of Patriot 1333 memory. Using stock cooling. Overclocked the processor to 3.8Ghz and runs perfectly stable at 100% load for hours.

Machine is very very fast. I'll let you know how renders compare to my Q6600 Quad core chip as soon as I have time.

VERY interested to see how it compares. Your spec is what I am considering, and you current setup is what I have.

Jeff Harper December 2nd, 2008 03:54 PM

That is unbelievable. Now I REALLY regret my recent "upgrade"!

Jon McGuffin December 2nd, 2008 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeff Harper (Post 971833)
That is unbelievable. Now I REALLY regret my recent "upgrade"!

The upgrades can go on and on Jeff... I remember your system build and I think you're probably doing pretty well. If memory serves correctly, despite you buying a new Fx1000 aren't you still doing most of your editing work in DV? I can't imagine that lasting very long... I7 is pretty expensive right now.. not so much the chips, but the mobo and memory... another year will probably bring in a new set of enhanced i7 chips at faster speeds with mobo's and memory coming far down... when it matures to that point, it'll probably make sense to upgrade once again... but it will probably be a fairly cheap upgrade for a large performance benefit..

Jon

Jeff Harper December 3rd, 2008 01:42 AM

My regret is about having made a less-than-intelligent and ill-informed purchase.

My new setup does run great, but I only do major upgrade every 1-2 years so this was a blunder on my part.

It is not just a matter of wanting "faster", etc. The i7 chips seem to be almost custom designed for Vegas and for video in general. As you know, these processors chew up video and spit it out. The i7 processor is a huge leap forward, and I believe $500 for the entry level chip is a phenomenal price.

Spent $300 on a motherboard and $200 on DDR2 RAM for a total of $500, all to support Socket 775 platform which is now outdated. This all came within two weeks of purchase of my MOBO.

Had thought the i7 was much farther off than it was; I just didn't see anything about the imminent release of these chips...really caught me off-guard.

While there is something to be said for waiting, in this case I'm not so sure. The new Gigabyte boards are great, and so far the reviews for this chip are nothing but glowing.

Alastair Brown December 3rd, 2008 10:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Warshaw (Post 969759)
I just built a Core i7 system with 3gb RAM and the 2.6 ghz processor. I had a 945D Dual Core with 4gb previously.

I am encoding VBR 2 pass SD DVD using TMPGenc frameserved from Vegas and Premier Pro CS3 with the Video Noise Reduction filter in TMPGenc enabled. Source is 1440x1080 HDV.

On my old system it would take around 11 hrs to encode 90 Mins of video.

Core i7 did it in under 2hrs with same settings. Not too shabby!!!

/billw

Bill,

How is your playback. What I am hoping you will say is that you have several HD clips on the timeline with effects added and you are getting a steady 25 fps playback (in red at bottom of preview screen) in BEST fULL.

Jeff Harper December 4th, 2008 06:06 AM

Following is a TYPICAL quote from a newegg customer regarding the $298 version of the i7 processor:

"This thing is a beast. The jump from my Q6600 to the i7 was huge. I have this thing running at 3.5Ghz on the first try and on the stock cooler with temps 33 degrees idle and 58 load. I'm not sure how far this chip will overclock but 3.5Ghz with a small voltage jump (may not have even needed the extra voltage) on the Intel stock cooler is awesome. The Q6600 at 3.5Ghz on the stock cooler would have caused global warming!"

This chip has hyperthreading. It does it all. It overclocks better than the Q6600. This is the chip to buy whether you overclock or not.

The Q6600 and the rest of that series are finished; they just don't know it yet. The phrase "dead man walking" comes to mind at this point.

The only issue is not if you should buy an i7, but when. The prices for these are insane. I would be pefectly content with the base model; it tears the Q6600 to shreds.

Out of 36 reviews for this chip, 35 of the reviewers gave it 5 eggs (for those that don't shop at Newegg that is the same as 5 stars or perfect). One reviewer took off points because they didn't like the heatsink.

Aside from many complaints regarding the heatsink there is nothing to be found but huge praise for this chip, particularly gamers and video editors. This chip was made for us.

Regarding the hyperthreading one reviewer says his shows up as 8 cores. With overclocking I can't even imagine the performance.

Congratulations to all who have made this move...

As Alastair said, can't wait to hear how it affects previewing.

Jon McGuffin December 4th, 2008 12:40 PM

Thanks for that post Jeff... I can picture you now crying in your milk over your recent upgrade all the way out here in California.... Your post is now making me rethink if I want to invest in a new system.. I think I'll probably do it sometime in late January... I'd be happy just to get an i7 at 3Ghz...

And I will second the request to find out how this chip is effecting Vegas playback performance because, as I've mentioned in the past, I can live with rendering times, let's face it I have to eat and sleep at some point so while not render during those times? But playback performance while I'm working is a legitimate concern for me and I've not been very happy with Vegas in this regard while manipulating HDV even at half the frame size..

Jon

Terry Esslinger December 4th, 2008 01:03 PM

Did I hear that if you bought the Dell system with the lower (2.6?) 7i chip that you could not overclock it?

Bill Warshaw December 4th, 2008 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastair Brown (Post 972602)
Bill,

How is your playback. What I am hoping you will say is that you have several HD clips on the timeline with effects added and you are getting a steady 25 fps playback (in red at bottom of preview screen) in BEST fULL.

I'll check this out tonight and report back to you. My playback of a single 23.976 HDV clip was rock solid at 23.976, using PREVIEW/FULL. I will try again with BEST/FULL. What kinda of effect would you like me to thow on the clip?

/BILLW

Bill Warshaw December 4th, 2008 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jon McGuffin (Post 972933)
Thanks for that post Jeff... I can picture you now crying in your milk over your recent upgrade all the way out here in California.... Your post is now making me rethink if I want to invest in a new system.. I think I'll probably do it sometime in late January... I'd be happy just to get an i7 at 3Ghz...

And I will second the request to find out how this chip is effecting Vegas playback performance because, as I've mentioned in the past, I can live with rendering times, let's face it I have to eat and sleep at some point so while not render during those times? But playback performance while I'm working is a legitimate concern for me and I've not been very happy with Vegas in this regard while manipulating HDV even at half the frame size..

Jon


Jon,

If you'd like to send me a small (30 second?) 8.0c project, I'll load it up and tell you how it looks. If you don't have a yousendit account (or something similar), they offer a 14 day trial.

/BILLW

Alastair Brown December 4th, 2008 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Warshaw (Post 972951)
I'll check this out tonight and report back to you. My playback of a single 23.976 HDV clip was rock solid at 23.976, using PREVIEW/FULL. I will try again with BEST/FULL. What kinda of effect would you like me to thow on the clip?

/BILLW

I think there is a render test clip somewhere that was used as the benchmark for us Vegas guys. Somebody care to point it out.

Dell have indeed launched systems with these cpu's and I doubt you could build one for less. REALLY tempting.

Corei7 920 2.66Ghz
MS Vista 64bit!
Free Creative VADO Camera (likely to be junk)
6GB Tri Channel Memory
2 x 320Gb 7200 SATA Hard Drives setup in RAID0
256Mb ATI Radeon HD3650 (anybody know how this rates for MB?)
6 x Blu Ray Burner Drive
Keyboard and Mouse

Comes in at £765 delivered. Prior to this, best I have seen for just a MOBO, cpu and 3Gb of memory was £613, so thats a heck of a lot extra for not a lot.

Jon McGuffin December 4th, 2008 02:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Warshaw (Post 972951)
I'll check this out tonight and report back to you. My playback of a single 23.976 HDV clip was rock solid at 23.976, using PREVIEW/FULL. I will try again with BEST/FULL. What kinda of effect would you like me to thow on the clip?

/BILLW

Awomse.. color correction! Also, what resolution are you previewing the image at?

Thanks Bill,

Jon

Alastair Brown December 4th, 2008 02:26 PM

Creative Vado Pocket Video Cam Video, Camcorder Reviews on CNET.co.uk

Review of the Creative Vado mentioned above. As expected....don't get too excited!

Mike Kujbida December 4th, 2008 02:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastair Brown (Post 972976)
I think there is a render test clip somewhere that was used as the benchmark for us Vegas guys. Somebody care to point it out.

NEW Rendertest-HDV.veg

Quad core render times initially were around the 2 min. mark.
Latest results are as follows.
Win Vista 64 Intel core i7 940 @ 2.93 GHz 6G ram Vegas 8.0c - 1:42
Win Vista 64 Intel core i7 940 @ 2.93 GHz 6G ram Vegas 8.1 - 1:08

Can you say WOW!!.
I know what I want Santa to bring me for Christmas :-)
If my wife sees this, it'll be over my dead body :-(

Jon McGuffin December 4th, 2008 04:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastair Brown (Post 972976)
I think there is a render test clip somewhere that was used as the benchmark for us Vegas guys. Somebody care to point it out.

Dell have indeed launched systems with these cpu's and I doubt you could build one for less. REALLY tempting.

Corei7 920 2.66Ghz
MS Vista 64bit!
Free Creative VADO Camera (likely to be junk)
6GB Tri Channel Memory
2 x 320Gb 7200 SATA Hard Drives setup in RAID0
256Mb ATI Radeon HD3650 (anybody know how this rates for MB?)
6 x Blu Ray Burner Drive
Keyboard and Mouse

Comes in at £765 delivered. Prior to this, best I have seen for just a MOBO, cpu and 3Gb of memory was £613, so thats a heck of a lot extra for not a lot.

Hmm.. I've hunted around the Dell site and was unable to locate such a cheap beast... That's an incredible price though considering it includes a blu Ray burner...

Jon

Alastair Brown December 4th, 2008 04:29 PM

The Dell Online Store: Build Your System

Not the exact spec I quoted. Do a search on their site for i7

Jon McGuffin December 4th, 2008 07:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastair Brown (Post 973048)
The Dell Online Store: Build Your System

Not the exact spec I quoted. Do a search on their site for i7

Yeah, here in the States the "Studio" series systems are only shipping with Core 2 Quads still.. When I try to price a Sudio XPS, the prices jump dramatically into the $1500 range..

Bill Warshaw December 4th, 2008 09:44 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jon McGuffin (Post 972979)
Awomse.. color correction! Also, what resolution are you previewing the image at?

Thanks Bill,

Jon

Here you go - Color Correction PLUS Levels Adjust on the source clip, which was 1080i 29.97fps. Rock solid on preview. See attached screenshot.

Alastair Brown December 4th, 2008 11:28 PM

Could the i7 be the Holy Grail that Vegas users have been looking for. Your rock solid frame rate looks very promising.

Andy Wilkinson December 5th, 2008 03:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastair Brown (Post 973220)
Could the i7 be the Holy Grail that Vegas users have been looking for. Your rock solid frame rate looks very promising.

Nah Alistair, you want one of these!!!!!! :-)

At "250 times the speed of a normal PC" and ONLY £4000 - £8000 (read £400 to £800 within 3 years?) it's all getting within reach.

World's first personal supercomputer unveiled - Telegraph

Alastair Brown December 5th, 2008 03:37 AM

OOOOOOOOoooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!

It's all very strange. CPU's went up in stages for ages then it seemed to hit a ceiling. They then started going dual core then quad.

Now the i7 has completely smashed and surpassed anything that is out there by a mile, and now stuff like this is coming.

Exciting times we live in!

You can actually buy one here.

http://www.nvidia.com/object/persona...computing.html

960 Parallel cores!

Keith Malone December 5th, 2008 06:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Kujbida (Post 972990)
NEW Rendertest-HDV.veg

Quad core render times initially were around the 2 min. mark.
Latest results are as follows.
Win Vista 64 Intel core i7 940 @ 2.93 GHz 6G ram Vegas 8.0c - 1:42
Win Vista 64 Intel core i7 940 @ 2.93 GHz 6G ram Vegas 8.1 - 1:08

Can you say WOW!!.
I know what I want Santa to bring me for Christmas :-)
If my wife sees this, it'll be over my dead body :-(

hi Mike

Amazing difference in render speed! What spec was your Quad core build?

Keith

Mike Kujbida December 6th, 2008 07:32 AM

Keith, I have a QX6700 and it came in at 01:59.

Alastair Brown December 6th, 2008 02:29 PM

Have caved in. All this info was too much to resist.

Talked them down to £720 inc vat and deliv and an uprated dual DVI graphics card, 2 x 320Gb in RAID0 and 6Gb of RAM. And YES, that price does include a Blu Ray Burner and a 64 bit O/S, and a free Creative Video Camera(go for around £70 on Ebay). Going to run 1Tb storage drives via eSATA.

Review

http://www.hexus.net/content/item.php?item=16444&page=1

Jon McGuffin December 6th, 2008 11:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alastair Brown (Post 973922)
Have caved in. All this info was too much to resist.

Talked them down to £720 inc vat and deliv and an uprated dual DVI graphics card, 2 x 320Gb in RAID0 and 6Gb of RAM. And YES, that price does include a Blu Ray Burner and a 64 bit O/S, and a free Creative Video Camera(go for around £70 on Ebay). Going to run 1Tb storage drives via eSATA.

Review

HEXUS.net - Review :: Dell Studio XPS: Intel's Core i7 system for £699 : Page - 1/10

That's fantastic... Do tell when you receive it how it performs for you...

Jim Andrada December 9th, 2008 10:10 AM

Just ordered a water cooled Boxx i7 system with the 3.2 Ghz chip and 6 GB of memory. The water cooling should permit the chip to overclock significantly - I hope. I got it primarily for 3D rendering (Cinema 4D, Vray, Fry Render) but am confident it will also be a huge improvement for video.

I'll find out for sure about two weeks hence when the machine arrives for Xmas.

The thing that impressed me most about the chip was that it seems to offer (via overclocking) a big performance boost for single/double threaded apps that don't take advantage of high levels of multi threading.

In particular, I run the RealFlow fluid simulator and they only support two threads unless you pay a bunch extra for a license that opens up higher levels of multithreading.

I hope I can say goodbye to 24 hour renders of a single image. But in reality I'll probably just crank up the resolution or add more lighting effects and get better results for the same 24 hours.

Jeff Harper December 9th, 2008 10:48 AM

The boys at Boxx do not play around. Their configurations seem to be as good as it gets.

Jim Andrada December 9th, 2008 10:59 AM

Yes, they seem to know what they're doing. Pretty familiar with most of the 3D apps. I've talked with them at SIGGRAPH a couple of times and was favorably impressed. This will be my first Boxx system.

David Johns December 9th, 2008 12:24 PM

Dell Studio XPS Core i7
 
Hello,

I too have just ordered the Dell Studio XPS Core i7 - the base spec (2.66GHz chip, 6GB RAM, 640GB hard drive, Vista 64), £683 including VAT and delivery. Also ordered their 2904W monitor for £183 - 1920x1080 24" monitor, seemed too good a bargain to miss, will use Vegas' preview to second monitor for full-HD preview on that.

Alas, delivery date is only given as "by or before Jan 6th" and customer support tell me that they've been rather overwhelmed by the demand.

Upgrading from a single-core Pentium 4 2.5GHz, this is going to be one heck of a difference!

Regards
David Johns

Jeff Harper December 9th, 2008 12:39 PM

Going from a Pentium 4? Be careful, your head might explode after you see it in action. At the least you will have to pinch yourself.

Alastair Brown December 9th, 2008 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David Johns (Post 975294)
Hello,

I too have just ordered the Dell Studio XPS Core i7 - the base spec (2.66GHz chip, 6GB RAM, 640GB hard drive, Vista 64), £683 including VAT and delivery. Also ordered their 2904W monitor for £183 - 1920x1080 24" monitor, seemed too good a bargain to miss, will use Vegas' preview to second monitor for full-HD preview on that.

Alas, delivery date is only given as "by or before Jan 6th" and customer support tell me that they've been rather overwhelmed by the demand.

Upgrading from a single-core Pentium 4 2.5GHz, this is going to be one heck of a difference!

Regards
David Johns

Hi David,

Hopefully we can compare happy notes!

Jonathan Gentry December 12th, 2008 11:27 AM

Guys

I'm not knocking the Dell. It will work great for you but building the system or buying a system with the Asus motherboard really is the way to go. You are leaving alot on the table if you don't overclock this chip. I'm at 3.6Ghz (3.8 ran fine but I backed it down just for good measure) on a 2.66 chip at only the cost of figuring how to overclock it in the bios. The machine will run at 100% utilization for as long as I like with no issues on the stock intel fan.

You may think this is going to blow things up but I've been running the Q6600 overclocked from 2.4 to 3.0Ghz for a long long time with no adverse effects. This i7 chip is much better at overclocking than even the q6600.

Just wanted to throw that point out there.

Alastair Brown December 12th, 2008 12:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jonathan Gentry (Post 976977)
Guys

I'm not knocking the Dell. It will work great for you but building the system or buying a system with the Asus motherboard really is the way to go. You are leaving alot on the table if you don't overclock this chip. I'm at 3.6Ghz (3.8 ran fine but I backed it down just for good measure) on a 2.66 chip at only the cost of figuring how to overclock it in the bios. The machine will run at 100% utilization for as long as I like with no issues on the stock intel fan.

You may think this is going to blow things up but I've been running the Q6600 overclocked from 2.4 to 3.0Ghz for a long long time with no adverse effects. This i7 chip is much better at overclocking than even the q6600.

Just wanted to throw that point out there.

Absolutely agree, however, you can't argue with the Dell price. With what you save, you could buy a clockable mobo and still have a LOT of change.

Terry Esslinger December 12th, 2008 01:49 PM

Does it cost hat much more to have one built?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:28 AM.

DV Info Net -- Real Names, Real People, Real Info!
1998-2025 The Digital Video Information Network